A nonprofit news organization covering the U.S. criminal justice system
About
Feedback?
support@themarshallproject.org
Tim Hess' responses to questions from the community.
In Ohio, Judges have a wide latitude of discretion when it comes to felony sentencing. I believe every case is different and each defendant should be treated on a case-by-case basis when it comes to sentencing.
Under the United States Constitution and the Constitution of Ohio, all men are created equal. Additionally, Lady Justice wears a blindfold to signify that justice is blind. The color of your skin, religious affiliation, sexual orientation, age, national origin, or socioeconomic background has no place in the courtroom. Everyone is to be treated equally under the law.
I believe in some instances they have gone too far. Too often we hear of a violent offender being released on a low bond only to get back out into the community and commit another heinous crime of violence. Community safety needs to take priority when setting bond/bail.
I have some conflicting ideas as to the election of judges versus appointment. If judges were to be appointed, I believe it should be done by a council formed from the electorate such as lawyers and various elected officials from both parties. I do not believe that if judges are to be appointed, that it should be done by the executive branch, particularly the administration of one executive office.
I believe in certain circumstances these programs are successful and a valuable asset to the court, the community, and to the defendant. The mental health court implemented in the Cuyahoga County Court of Common Pleas has come a long way, and like many other things in our system, it can always be improved. I would like to implement a system through our probation department that finds low level offenders and persons charged with drug crimes a job in our community. Cleveland is well known for being a union town. I would like to see our courts and probation department work with local unions to find probationers jobs within the unions and trades.
First and foremost, a conversation should be had with an aggrieved family of a victim as to why the decisions that were made were necessary. That goes the same way for the family of an offender who may receive a lengthy prison sentence. An acceptable explanation to the family of the defendant may help them understand the decisions that were made by the Court.